“How’s the Cinsaut coming?” I asked our vineyard manager, Chuck Mansfield.
We used to grow Cinsaut ourselves, but a lack of water in the vineyard opposite our tasting room forced us to make some very difficult decisions. One of those was abandoning our Cinsaut block. Before doing so, we asked Chuck if he could find another source so we could continue bottling this popular variety.
Over the years, we’ve purchased Cinsaut from several El Dorado vineyards, including Veerkamp, Futternick and Swansboro.
“There isn’t any,” Chuck replied.
What?!
It had been a strange year in the vineyards. A warm winter brought an early budbreak, and although I’m not aware of any significant frost in the foothills, the vines were flowering during unsettled spring weather. The result was a very small crop for many varieties. Here at Holly’s Hill, Viognier and Grenache were hit the hardest.
I started checking around.
I asked Paul Bush at Madroña about a vineyard near the top of Snows Road, not far from us. I believe he’d taken the entire crop the previous year, partly as a favor to the grower. Unfortunately, that vineyard had a light crop too, and it had already been picked.
Even though it was only early October, the vineyards were looking more like early November. Many were already shutting down and beginning to show fall color.
I couldn’t find any Cinsaut.
A Trip to Lodi
Carrie lamented to her friend Thaya, who works for Marco Cappelli. Through Marco we got a contact for a grower in Lodi. After several texts back and forth, we were on our way a couple of days later, with empty picking bins in the back of the truck in case the fruit looked good.
We’d punted to Lodi before. In 2022, a particularly harsh frost cost us not only fruit but entire vines. That year, we purchased Viognier and Roussanne from the Ripken Vineyard.
Lodi vineyards look like another world to this hillbilly. Not only is everything flat, but I could hardly walk down the rows. The silty soil is so light and loose that it’s like walking through the finest beach sand you’ve ever felt.
The fruit, however, tasted great.
We dropped off our bins and took a sample back to test at the winery, but not before discovering that our socks and shoes had been attacked by some of the biggest and ugliest stickers we’d ever seen!
Back at the winery, the numbers weren’t quite as encouraging as the flavor. The sugar content was low, which wasn’t surprising considering the size of the crop. Interestingly, the grapes didn’t taste under-ripe because the acidity was also low. That wasn’t a huge concern since we could add tartaric acid after crushing.
What concerned me more was the color.
When tasting red grapes, I’ll sometimes chew on the skins for a few seconds and then spit out a little saliva to get an idea of how much color they contain.
My spit wasn’t exactly dark.
Sorry for the frank talk, but these are the things winemakers do.
Carrie and I talked it over. If the resulting wine didn’t meet our expectations, we could always blend it into Rockbound, our Syrah-based blend sold through grocery stores and Costco.
But that would leave us a wine short. We like having enough different wines to offer our wine club throughout the year, and losing Cinsaut would leave a hole in the lineup.
So we kept looking.
Another Dead End
Element 79 had some Petite Sirah available. We drove out with high hopes and, once again, empty bins in the back of the truck. Unfortunately, there was probably only a bin’s worth of fruit left, and most of it had turned to raisins.
Carrie suggested Cabernet Franc.
We think Cabernet Franc grows beautifully up here, and with our winery trip to Bordeaux coming up next year, the timing couldn’t have been better. Maybe this was an opportunity to try something different.
I started reaching out again.
A winery in Camino had advertised Cabernet Franc for sale. I contacted the owner, but he’d already sold it.
He did, however, have Lagrein.
What’s that?
Turns out it’s an Italian variety from northern Italy. The grower said he had two tons hanging. Could we make it? It certainly wasn’t a Rhône variety, which is our niche, but I started researching it and discovered that it’s a distant relative of Syrah.
We could sell this!
I drove out to see the vineyard, bins in the back of the truck once again. The grower had warned me about deer damage, and he wasn’t kidding. What was supposed to be two tons looked more like one bin of fruit.
And wow, was it tart.
It needed another couple of weeks on the vine for the acidity to mellow, but at the rate the deer were eating, there wasn’t going to be anything left by then.
Another dead end.
Back to Chuck
I reached back out to Chuck and asked if he had anything available at any of the many vineyards he farms.
He had Aglianico.
Hmm.
I didn’t have much experience with Aglianico either. Another Italian variety, this one from southern Italy. I looked it up and found a research paper suggesting a distant genetic relationship with Syrah, although more recent research has questioned that connection.
Interesting nonetheless.
Chuck brought us a sample, and wow! The skins were incredibly tannic, with an almost chalky intensity. It was a big wine in the making, but it clearly needed more time on the vine.
A week later, we got another sample. It was still huge, but during our conversation Chuck casually mentioned that he also had some Cabernet Franc he wasn’t planning on picking because of the grape market.
What?!
“Why didn’t you tell me?”
He said he’d go check it out.

Other than spraying for mildew, he hadn’t done much of the work he would normally do in that vineyard, like suckering and thinning. The crop was big, and the numbers reflected it. It needed more time too.
Another week went by, and we got samples of both varieties.
By this point, Carrie had pretty much given up on the Aglianico idea in favor of the Cabernet Franc. I mentioned this to Chuck, but he explained that for crop insurance reasons, he’d really like to sell the Aglianico too.
We talked it over and agreed to take both.
I told Carrie that worst-case scenario, the Aglianico could go into Rockbound.
Win-win.
So How Did It All Turn Out?
Well, we’re still finding out.

The Cinsaut is a bit light, as I’d feared, but the flavor is quite good. After tasting it, I started thinking it might make a nice base for our Lover’s Leap, our Côtes du Rhône-style blend. A little Syrah could provide the color and structure it’s missing, and we might end up with something really nice.
The Cabernet Franc is particularly interesting. It has quite a bit of that green bell pepper character associated with methoxypyrazines, compounds that are especially noticeable in Cabernet Franc grown in cooler conditions. It’s a character I associate with some of the wines of the Loire Valley and cooler parts of Bordeaux. Not necessarily what you’d expect from California, but that’s part of what makes it interesting.
And then there’s the Aglianico.
It’s incredibly dark, with some pretty formidable tannins. It’s still finishing fermentation, and there’s just enough residual sugar to soften the impression of what’s lurking underneath. Once that sugar is gone, I suspect we’re going to have a very serious wine on our hands.
There are only two barrels, so not enough to bottle on it own, but it should be a great addition to Syrah for our big Rockbound blend.
Now the truck gets a break from hauling bins. Instead, it’ll be pulling our camping trailer for a little R&R.
First stop? Bend, Oregon.
And if you read my blog The Beer of the Summer, you probably have a pretty good idea where we’ll be.
Josh Bendick
Co-winemaker
4 Responses
That was far better than a government report, thanks Josh…. will you do one every year??
Do I have to???
I was looking forward to tasting a true varietal Aglianico made by Carrie and Josh. 😉But I’ll settle for it blended.
Well, you never know😏